Spirited Exchanges
Welcome Guest Search | Active Topics | Members | Log In | Register

Does divorce and remarrying in the church create chaos in Christ Options · View
Ruth
Posted: Monday, September 18, 2006 11:25:38 PM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 9/18/2006
Posts: 2
Points: 0
Location: Wellington
I am a divorced Lady,due to a manoverly interested in just church and not enough to do with home life and myself,at least tht is ho wi saw it?.I amnow remarrie dand wonder didn't I pray enough about our marriage the 1st and would i have been still withthe same husband had i handed it over to God more than I did then? and is it worth it? pain of divorce and remariage and all the problems tht come with a new relationship (marriage).
My children all grown up and married with their own children,stil I am goin g through a lot of grief.I'd appreciate a few opinions too or experience of their situatioons if similar.
Thanks
Ruth
anton
Posted: Tuesday, September 19, 2006 10:00:05 AM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 9/19/2006
Posts: 1
Points: 0
Location: near Christchurch
Hi,
I see divorce as not a piece of paper that says your marriage is over but the situation that exists when both partners in a marriage or relationship aren't actively trying to make it work for the benefit of them both.
otherside532
Posted: Sunday, October 15, 2006 1:20:40 AM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 9/10/2006
Posts: 1
Points: 0
Location: Northland, New Zealand
Hello. I am a total newcomer here so I hope that you will bear with me and any errors that I may make.
I was interested to read both comments here and I would like to reply to both.


I was interested in Ruth's comment/question, about "handing it over to God more." What are your views on "Predestination," Ruth? Do we REALLY have choices or ARE we all predestined to do what we do, thinking that we make choices? Does prayer REALLY work? We all hear/read/see the answers to prayer that are trumpeted around, but what about those who's prayers AREN'T answered? I have come t the conclusion that answers to prayer are like winning the lottery, those answered (the winners) get lots of publicity with the view of selling more tickets (getting more converts) those who's aren't answered, the "non winners " disappear into oblivion and are not heard of again, unless they do become a winner.

If predestination is what the bible seems (to me at least) to say it is, then you, Ruth, were predestined to marry and get divorced from your first husband and marry your second (current) husband. Predestination is a subject that I have had, and am still having, a lot of problems with. If you are interested Ruth, you could go and check out and check out "St. Pixels" where there is a discussion on Predestination

As far as Anton goes, I would not altogether agree with his reasoning. My first marriage was not good, a lot was my fault I admit it, but then I started to try to make up for the past and make it work but my, now wx, wife didn't want to continue and told me toleave while she decided whether or not she wanted a divorce. She decidee that she did and so it happened. I had occasion to speak to her one one occasion some time afterwards and she admitted that she had made a mistake giving me the boot. I am not saying this to brag, but to say that I don't believe that both partners are not actively trying to make it work.

I could go on but it is late now and the land of Nod is calling. Bye folks
Michelle
Posted: Friday, November 10, 2006 7:06:43 PM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 11/1/2005
Posts: 1
Points: 0
Hi, everyone,

Regarding predestination - I think of this as God seeing what will happen in the future from the beginning, since he is at the beginning at at the end simultaneously. So, when he sets up a certain course of action with Jesus coming, God sees ahead to who will respond to Christ and who will not - hence, from God's perspective it is 'predestined' who will follow him. However, this in no way detracts from our own choice which has power to determine our eternal fate.

The entire Bible is based on the premise that we have choice as well as the reality that God is in control - and this is how I bring those two realities together.

Regarding prayer - I saw an interesting article on Close Up about Bill Subritzky and Faith Healing recently. A woman expressed her scepticism about prayer by pointing out that everyone who died in the Titanic would have prayed for God to deliver them, not just those who were saved. True enough. But the point is that how God answers prayer is actually God's choice - he is, after all (assuming we agree he exists) a person too. In fact, he is more than a person - he is God. If this is the case, then there must be a multitude of issues that he takes into account in how he responds. I have never looked to response to prayer (in material provision, anyhow) as evidence for or against God - rather, to me the issue of his existence is better debated around the evidence for the resurrection of Christ and hence the authority of Christ's words.

Ruth - regarding divorce, I feel sorrow for you. I'm sorry that your first marriage ended, and I think your grief is entirely appropriate. I think the marriage covenant is something that means very different things for different people depending on how it is applied - it was orginally given to us to be lifelong, and how far we have fallen from this intention. I hope for God's healing and restoration for you.

Anton - I think I agree with what you're saying: divorce is something that can happen in the heart well before it happens in writing.
vxrider
Posted: Saturday, March 03, 2007 2:19:58 PM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/3/2007
Posts: 1
Points: 0
Location: Eastern Waikato, NZ
Shalom everyone
As you can see from my joining date, this is my very first post into the Spirited Exchanges forum, having discovered this site thru Jamieson et al's books A Churchless Faith, and Five Years On. Please bear with me as an enthusiastic newbie who may try to run before he can walk.

I would like to contribute by way of brief (hopefully!) commentry and a recommendation of three books.

I pretty much agree with Michelle's & Otherside's perspectives on prayer & predestination. For a seriously heart & mind expanding experience on the nature and relationships between Choice-of-Attitude, Destiny & ultimate Enternity, may I reccomend "The Great Divorce", by C.S. Lewis. I personally feel it is his finest work, and that all of his other theological books are "mere" exegetical expansions & practical-reality expressions, of the core themes & concepts in the Great Divorce.

The book's title is potentially misleading. To quote from the back cover blurb, Lewis is addressing the question
"...can good and evil be reconciled? Is the marriage of Heaven and Hell, of which the poet William Blake wrote, a possibility? [Lewis's answer] is an emphatic 'No'. The Divorce must be absolute, and we must choose which path we will follow, for 'if we insist on keeping Hell (or even Earth) we shall not see Heaven: if we accept Heaven, we shall not be able to retain even the smallest and most intimate souvenirs of Hell'.

Which goes to show that (some types of) Divorce can be a Very Good Thing!

Perhaps the most charitable viewpoint on Calvinist predestination is to equate it (at the theological/spiritual level) in similar fashion to the macro-order arising from the micro disorderly activity of Chaos Theory.

I am tempted to suggest it's unwise to ask of God for a deteministic expression or "directive" revelation of His "Will" in the minutiae of our daily decision-making both small and large (from our perspective). Rather, it's better to ask "How do I act in the Spirit of Agape?" which also includes Oneself, as well as others!

Secondly, regarding divorce/remarriage. Ruth, aroha and compassion from me to you, even though I haven't walked that path as you have.

I am wondering if your grief and inner struggle has its roots in a sense of failure to live up to (what I personally believe is), a pharisaic party-political line followed by the institutional church, that has come about through a major failure to exegete scripture in its proper historical and cultural context.

May I reccomend 2 books by David Instone-Brewer, "Divorce & Remarriage In the Bible: The Social & Literary Context", and also "Divorce & Remarriage in The Church". He also has a website, instone-brewer.com (with the usual wx3 prefix) which had a considerable resource set.

Perhaps these will be an answer to your heartfelt prayer and restoration of your inner Shalom. John 8:32 - Then you will know the Truth, and the Truth will set you free.

John
stpu22
Posted: Sunday, March 04, 2007 7:12:09 AM
Rank: Newbie
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2007
Posts: 1
Points: 0
Location: Eastern Canada, CANADA.
Hello Ruth,

Peace to you. Rest in the knowledge that we cannot always do the right thing at the right time in the right way. It's part of being human. But having said that, I'm sure you did what you believed to be the best at the time. That is really all that can take place. Were you acting irresponsibly prior to the divorce? Were you unkind, unfeeling and bitter? Were you delibaretly working to make things as hard and as awful with your ex husband? I some how doubt you were any of these things. So please be kind to yourself in looking back. "Giving over to God" could also be phrased as "Giving up. Letting God do what only he can do." This releases you from feeling you have to fix things. Sometimes we may be able to " fix things ". But often we can't. God has to step in through people and circumstances and do the fixing. And if the separation and eventual divorce were part of his work, then we have to come and accept that, though I don't say that flippantly. It is hard. It is severe, but it is often the way of love for both concerned.

I'm not quite sure if your divorce was recently or awhile ago, but grief has a way of revisiting us. And I do understand, for I am also in a grieving situation over my own divorce, which took effect 22 January. I grieve the good times, the excellent family times we had for 20 years, that I'm not right on the spot now with my sons (youngest is 12), and lots more besides. But I have been going round in the grief cycle and have come to realise that I am stuck in it! That can happen, and often requires help from an outside party to enable us to see why we're stuck and how to move on. In time we have to move out of the grief, otherwise I believe we stay in a destructive pattern of either self blame and guilt, or bitterness, anger and blaming, or depression and self pity. None are very good for us!

With all this remember that God does not judge you. He does not stand there pointing his finger at you because you "didn't do quite enough" and thus you are to blame. Not at all. And if he isn't doing that, then you don't need to do it either. You can relax! Rest back in that knowledge and in the fact that you are loved...tremendously loved by Him (and Her!) God is so much more than we often realise and I think the traits of mercy, grace, acceptance and love are some of those traits we so often forget, when we think that maybe we have "done bad".

If you can do some hard thinking, pinpoint what you are feeling/thinking and where you're at in regards to the divorce, then try and think outside yourself in gaining some proper perspective ( or sit with someone, a professional
psychologist or psychotherapist if need be) to help you with the process. This outside perspective is sometimes all we need. And in the midst of all that God can come to do the healing and freeing that you and he both want for you.

Get someone to give you a lot of hugs and affirmation too. I have this from various friends and it helps breakdown the negative thoughts I very easily swim around in sometimes!

Shalom...rest...experience Joy...experience God and his love
Stephen.
Users browsing this topic
Guest


Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Main Forum RSS : RSS

ASPNET Theme created by Boskone (Dan Ferguson)
Powered by Yet Another Forum.net version 1.9.0 (NET v2.0) - 10/10/2006
Copyright © 2003-2006 Yet Another Forum.net. All rights reserved.
This page was generated in 0.279 seconds.